When Should You Sell XEQT? (Almost Never)
Most reasons people have for selling XEQT are wrong. A few are right. Knowing the difference is genuinely important to your financial outcome.
Good reasons to sell XEQT
These are the situations where selling some or all of your XEQT is the correct financial decision. They are all variations of one theme: you have a genuine, planned use for the money.
Bad reasons to sell XEQT
These are the reasons most people actually sell XEQT. None of them are good ones. Most of them will cost you money.
| Reason given for selling | Why it is wrong |
|---|---|
| The market is down | Markets always recover. Selling locks in the loss permanently. |
| I think a crash is coming | Nobody has reliably predicted market crashes in advance. You will probably be wrong and miss the recovery. |
| "I heard things are bad" / news anxiety | Financial media profits from fear. Scary news is not correlated with market returns. Markets went up on average through every geopolitical crisis of the last century. |
| XEQT has been flat for a year | One year of flat returns is normal and expected. A ten-year holding period is the minimum meaningful measurement window. |
| Someone on Reddit said X is better | Switching to a different ETF based on recent performance is chasing returns. The fund that outperformed last year often underperforms next year. |
| I want to wait for a better entry point | Every study on market timing shows that most investors who sell to wait for a better price buy back in at higher prices. Time in market beats timing the market. |
| I want to lock in my gains | Gains in a TFSA do not need locking in. The tax is not coming. Growth inside a TFSA is yours permanently, whether you sell or not. |
Retirement drawdown: selling with intention
When you reach retirement and begin drawing on your portfolio, selling XEQT should be systematic and planned, not reactive. The recommended approach is to sell only what you need for the next twelve months of living expenses and keep the rest invested. This way, the majority of your portfolio continues compounding while you draw on the portion you need.
Many retirees maintain a "cash bucket" of one to two years of living expenses in a high-interest savings account alongside their XEQT portfolio. This cash buffer means they never have to sell XEQT during a market downturn. When XEQT is up, they top up the cash bucket by selling some units. When XEQT is down, they live off the cash bucket and wait for recovery.
This bucket strategy removes the sequence-of-returns risk (being forced to sell at a low price early in retirement) that is the biggest financial danger for Canadian retirees with equity-heavy portfolios.
The rebalancing case: planned selling is fine
Selling XEQT to transition toward XGRO or XBAL as you approach retirement is not panic selling or market timing. It is lifecycle investing. The trigger for this transition should be age and time horizon, not market conditions. The XEQT vs XGRO comparison explains the full mechanics of when and how to make that shift. "I am 55 and want to reduce my equity exposure" is a good reason to sell XEQT. "The market fell and I am scared" is not.
Make the transition gradually over one to three years rather than in a single transaction. This reduces the risk of transitioning at a particularly bad time for either buying bonds or selling equities. Selling 20% to 30% of your XEQT position and buying XGRO each year for three years is a sensible approach with minimal market timing risk.
Tax-loss harvesting: only in non-registered accounts
This is a legitimate reason to sell XEQT, but it only applies in non-registered accounts and only when XEQT is sitting at an unrealized capital loss. If you have XEQT in your TFSA or RRSP, tax-loss harvesting is irrelevant. Losses inside registered accounts have no tax value.
The mechanics: sell XEQT, crystallize the capital loss, immediately buy VEQT (or another similar but not identical fund) to maintain market exposure. Wait 30 days (to avoid CRA superficial loss rules), then decide whether to switch back to XEQT or stay in VEQT. The capital loss can be carried back three years or forward indefinitely to offset future capital gains.
Major life changes
Major changes in your financial situation can legitimately justify selling XEQT: a divorce requiring asset division, a health crisis requiring significant funds, job loss with no emergency fund, a family emergency. These are not investment decisions. They are life events that require liquidity. Selling XEQT in these situations is the right call.
This is also why the emergency fund matters so much. An investor with six months of expenses in a savings account can hold XEQT through almost any personal financial disruption without being forced to sell at an inopportune moment.
The true cost of selling early
Selling $50,000 of XEQT at age 40 to sit in cash for two years and re-enter at the "right time" is not a neutral decision. At 7% annual return, those two years of being out of the market cost you approximately $7,245. Additionally, in a TFSA, re-contributing the $50,000 after withdrawing it uses $50,000 of new contribution room that may not be immediately available to you, potentially leaving your capital outside the tax shelter for a full calendar year.
The costs of premature selling are asymmetric: the upside of selling (catching a market decline or buying back at a lower price) requires you to be right twice in a row at exactly the right time. The downside of staying invested (experiencing paper losses during a decline) is temporary and historical recovers. The math heavily favours staying invested.
What to do instead of selling
If you are considering selling XEQT for a reason not on the good-reasons list, here are alternatives that address the underlying concern without locking in losses or missing recoveries:
The sell checklist
Before selling any XEQT, work through this checklist:
The best strategy: buy and hold.
Open a Wealthsimple TFSA, buy XEQT, and hold it for decades. Commission-free. $25 on your first deposit.
Open Wealthsimple → Get $25 Free